AlbertO.Hirschman《Exit, Voice, and Loyalty》作品简介与读书感悟

期刊简介:《美国政治学杂志》(AmericanJournalofPoliticalScience,AJPS)致力于在公民身份、治理和政治等知识领域取得重大进展。作为中西部政治科学协会的官方期刊,AJP

期刊简介:《美国政治学杂志》(American Journal of Political Science,AJPS)致力于在公民身份、治理和政治等知识领域取得重大进展。作为中西部政治科学协会的官方期刊,AJPS发表所有政治学领域的相关研究,包括美国政治、公共政策、国际关系、比较政治学、政治学方法论和政治学理论等。根据2018年Journal Citation Reports显示,其2018年的影响因子为4.354,在176种政治科学类期刊中排名第2(2/176)。

期刊目录

1.温度是外生变量吗?非洲内战对于工具性气候记录的影响

Is Temperature Exogenous? The Impact of Civil Conflict on the Instrumental Climate Record in Sub‐Saharan Africa

2.外国公民与规范移民:污名化特征会影响拉美族裔对歧视的判断吗?

Alien Citizens and the Canonical Immigrant: Do Stigmatized Attributes Affect Latina/o Judgment about Discrimination?

3.继承制度影响了政治和社会的不平等吗?

帮忙选下列其中三部名著,写出书的内容简介、精彩片段、读书感悟! 《西游记》、《水浒传》、《朝花夕拾》、《骆驼祥子》、《繁星春水》《鲁滨孙漂流记》、《童年》(高尔基)、《名人传》(罗曼罗兰)、《格列佛游记》、《钢铁是怎样炼成的。

Do Inheritance Customs Affect Political and Social Inequality?

4. 共和主义式自由、大众控制和集体行动

Republican Freedom,Popular Control,and Collective Action

齐刷刷、朝夕相伴、如法炮制、格格不入、无所适从、顺理成章、一动不动、此起彼伏、绘声绘色、昏昏欲睡、如梦如幻、结结实实、忍俊不禁、无恶不作、莫名其妙、三下两下、大汗淋漓。

5.用意识形态证成道德:政治信念预测道德基础

6.收看、不收看:评估族群电视台对政治参与的影响

7. 掌握正确事实如何强化政党支持者主导的推理

How Getting the Facts Right Can Fuel Partisan-Motivated Reasoning

8. 维和人员与暴力犯罪:维和行动的意外影响

Peacekeepers against Criminal Violence—Unintended Effects of Peacekeeping Operations?

9.贫困和神恩:伊斯兰政党的选举优势

Poverty and Divine Rewards: The Electoral Advantage of Islamist Political Parties

10.话语型退出

Discursive Exit

11.当激进政党进入议会时选民会两极分化吗?

文中描写的中心人物是一个地下党员的女儿.当时国民党反动派残酷地逮捕屠杀地下党员,白色恐怖笼罩着重庆上空.这姑娘的父亲因党组织遭到破坏而离开了家.母亲也因受到追踪特务的殴打而吐了血,然而,这位小姑娘不像一般孩子那样惊惶。

Do Voters Polarize When Radical Parties Enter Parliament?

12.政党的主要偏好:族裔、性别与议会主要候选人的政党支持

The Party's Primary Preferences: Race,Gender,and Party Support of Congressional Primary Candidates

13.导致选举权受限的选票改革:来自巴西第二共和国的证据

AlbertO.Hirschman《Exit, Voice, and Loyalty》作品简介与读书感悟

Ballot Reform as Suffrage Restriction: Evidence from Brazil's Second Republic

14.政治中的损失规避

Loss Aversion in Politics

你的人,因为他磨练了你的心态;感激拌倒你的人,因为他强化了你的双腿;感激欺骗你的人,因为他增进了你的智慧;感激蔑视你的人因为他觉醒了你的自尊;感激遗弃你的人,因为他教会了你独立。”是她对人生的感悟。

15.坚定的民主人士还是有条件的民主人士?选举威权中反对派联盟的流变

Committed or Conditional Democrats? Opposition Dynamics in Electoral Autocracies

一、温度是外生变量吗?

非洲内战对于工具性气候记录的影响

题目:Is Temperature Exogenous? The Impact of Civil Conflict on the Instrumental Climate Record in Sub‐Saharan Africa

Research into the effects of climate on political and economic outcomes assumes that short‐term variation in weather is exogenous to the phenomena being studied. However,weather data are derived from stations operated by national governments,whose political capacity and stability affect the quality and continuity of coverage. We show that civil conflict risk in sub‐Saharan Africa is negatively correlated with the number and density of weather stations contributing to a country's temperature record. This effect is both cross‐sectional—countries with higher average conflict risk tend to have poorer coverage—and cross‐temporal—civil conflict leads to loss of weather stations. Poor coverage induces a small downward bias in one widely used temperature data set,due to its interpolation method,and increases measurement error,potentially attenuating estimates of the temperature–conflict relationship. Combining multiple observational data sets to reduce measurement error almost doubles the estimated effect of temperature anomalies on civil conflict risk.

二、外国公民与规范移民:

污名化特征会影响拉美族裔对歧视的判断吗?

题目:Alien Citizens and the Canonical Immigrant: Do Stigmatized Attributes Affect Latina/o Judgment about Discrimination?

摘要:精英与新闻媒体对拉丁族裔议题的负面关注,特别在非法移民方面的关注,近年来快速增加。而这种负面关注可能会为拉丁族裔的移民地位和语言使用等特征蒙上污名。与此同时,移民政策的变迁导致了对拉丁族裔的大规模拘捕与驱逐。本文提出了两个问题:第一,拉丁族裔在多大程度上感知并经历了歧视?第二,移民身份、世代身份与语言使用在多大程度上塑造了其对歧视的看法?根据皮尤全国拉美族裔调查数据,本文发现拉美族裔对歧视问题的看法是一个关于”规范移民“的”邻近度“递减函数,这里的”规范移民“指的是以西班牙语为主的第一代移民。此外,本文证明了因歧视而受害的报导率并没有明显的规律,并且随时间的推移而趋于平稳。本文的结论是,歧视观念对系统性信任、焦虑和政策偏好有重大影响。

Negative elite and news media attention to Latino‐relevant issues,particularly undocumented immigration,has dramatically increased in recent years,potentially stigmatizing attributes of Latinos such as immigration status and language use. Concomitantly,immigration policy changes were leading to widespread arrests and deportation of many Latinos. Herein,we ask two questions: First,to what extent do Latinos perceive and experience discrimination? Second,to what extent do immigration status,generational status,and language use moderate beliefs about discrimination? Using Pew National Survey of Latinos data,we find that Latino beliefs about the problem of discrimination is a decreasing function of “proximity” to the “canonical immigrant”—defined here as first‐generation immigrants who are Spanish‐language dominant. Further,we demonstrate that reported rates of victimization due to discrimination exhibit no clear pattern and are flat over time. We conclude by demonstrating that discrimination beliefs have significant implications for systemic trust,anxiety,and policy preferences.

三、继承制度影响了政治和社会的不平等吗?

题目:Do Inheritance Customs Affect Political and Social Inequality?

摘要:为什么一些社会比其他社会更不平等?法国的革命家认为,是子女中不平等的继承制度造就了古代国家严格的等级制。因此,为了实现平等,革命家必须推动平等的继承权利,他们的目标在于提高女性的权利并且剥夺贵族阶级的特权。但是平等的继承制度真的提高了社会竞争环境的公平性吗?德国各地因为在继承制度上有明显差异,其历史上就致力于平等分配财富的城市到今天选举了更多的女性进入议会,而且社会精英中的贵族也减少了,由此德国成为我们研究的对象。通过对这一历史数据的分析,本文提出关于财富平等与平等主义者偏好的两条机制。最后,本文也指出,与直觉相反的是,平等的继承制度对收入不平等有着正向预测关系。本文认为这些发现意味着平等的继承制度通过奖励才华而非提升社会地位来提高竞争环境的公平性。

AlbertO.Hirschman《Exit, Voice, and Loyalty》作品简介与读书感悟

Why are some societies more unequal than others? The French revolutionaries believed unequal inheritances among siblings to be responsible for the strict hierarchies of the ancient régime. To achieve equality,the revolutionaries therefore enforced equal inheritance rights. Their goal was to empower women and to disenfranchise the noble class. But do equal inheritances succeed in leveling the societal playing field? We study Germany—a country with pronounced local‐level variation in inheritance customs—and find that municipalities that historically equally apportioned wealth,to this day,elect more women into political councils and have fewer aristocrats in the social elite. Using historic data,we point to two mechanisms: wealth equality and pro‐egalitarian preferences. In a final step,we also show that,counterintuitively,equitable inheritance customs positively predict income inequality. We interpret this finding to mean that equitable inheritances level the playing field by rewarding talent,not status.

四、用意识形态证成道德:

政治信念预测道德基础

作者自称“1924年以前不太懂俄语,而双目夫明前也只上过一年函授共产主义大学:因作品塑造了保尔·柯察金这个有着钢铁般意志的共产主义战土的形象和作家自身经历的传奇品质,《钢铁是怎样炼成的》成为世界革命青年成才的“教科书”和“圣经”。

题目:Ideology Justifies Morality: Political Beliefs Predict Moral Foundations

摘要:道德基础理论( Moral Foundations Theory ,MTF)被用作对意识形态的因果解释,该理论认为政治态度是道德直觉的产物。然而,先前的理论提出了相反的因果解释路径,即道德判断为政治信念所驱动。但是这两种现存的研究都只是假设性的,而不是明确地检验其因果关系。所以,是道德直觉驱动了政治信念,抑或是政治信念驱动了道德直觉?通过两个小组研究数据和一个全国性代表研究数据,我们实证地解决了这个问题,并且找到了意识形态预测道德直觉的一致证据。这项发现对于MFT作为一种意识形态理论有着重大意义,并且也对政治信念形塑个人如何合理化对错的结果有重大意义。

Moral Foundations Theory (MFT) is employed as a causal explanation of ideology that posits political attitudes are products of moral intuitions. Prior theoretical models,however,suggest the opposite causal path,that is,that moral judgments are driven by political beliefs. In both instances,however,extant research has assumed rather than explicitly tested for causality. So do moral intuitions drive political beliefs or do political beliefs drive moral intuitions? We empirically address this question using data from two panel studies and one nationally representative study,and find consistent evidence supporting the hypothesis that ideology predicts moral intuitions. The findings have significant implications for MFT as a theory of ideology,and also about the consequences of political beliefs for shaping how individuals rationalize what is right and what is wrong.

五、共和主义式自由、

大众控制和集体行动

题目:Republican Freedom,Popular Control,and Collective Action

Republicans hold that people are dominated merely in virtue of others’ having unconstrained abilities to frustrate their choices. They argue further that public officials may dominate citizens unless subject to popular control. Critics identify a dilemma. To maintain the possibility of popular control,republicans must attribute to the people an ability to control public officials merely in virtue of the possibility that they might coordinate their actions. But if the possibility of coordination suffices for attributing abilities to groups,then,even in the best case,countless groups will be dominating because it will be possible for their members to coordinate their actions with the aim of frustrating others’ choices. We argue the dilemma is apparent only. To make our argument,we present a novel interpretation of the republican concept of domination with the help of a game-theoretic model that clarifies the significance of collective action problems for republican theory.

六、收看、不收看:

评估族群电视台对政治参与的影响

题目:Tuning In,Not Turning Out: Evaluating the Impact of Ethnic Television on Political Participation

摘要:尽管族群电视台在移民社区中很重要,但是它在政治参与上的作用并不清楚。一方面,族群性的传媒能够动员和通知选民。另一方面,它也可以作为分散和削弱政治参与意愿的来源。为了评估这两种相对立的假设,我们利用两个州西班牙语电视台在联邦通讯委员会接收边界的数据,并对其进行了地理断点回归(GRD)分析。此外,我们利用三个具有族裔代表性的拉丁裔样本复现了我们GRD的分析结果。通过多重研究方法,我们发现收看西班牙语电视与投票率、政治参与和政治支持呈负相关。最后,我们讨论了这一发现对族群政治,政治传播和社会资本文献的影响。

AlbertO.Hirschman《Exit, Voice, and Loyalty》作品简介与读书感悟

Despite the importance of ethnic television within immigrant communities,its effects on political participation are unclear. On the one hand,ethnic media can mobilize and inform voters. On the other hand,it can serve as a source of diversion and reduce the desire to participate. To evaluate these competing possibilities,we implement a geographic regression discontinuity (GRD) approach involving Federal Communication Commission reception boundaries for Spanish-language television stations in two states. Additionally,we replicate and unpack our GRD analyses using three nationally representative samples of Latinos. Across multiple studies,we find that access to Spanish-language television is associated with decreases in turnout,ethnic civic participation,and political knowledge. We conclude by discussing the implications of these findings on the ethnic politics,political communication,and social capital literatures.

七、掌握正确事实如何强化政党支持者主导的推理

题目:How Getting the Facts Right Can Fuel Partisan-Motivated Reasoning

Scholars often evaluate citizens’ democratic competence by focusing on their ability to get relevant facts right. In this article,I show why this approach can yield misleading conclusions about citizen competence. I argue that although citizens with strong partisan loyalties might be forced to accept the same facts,they find alternative ways to rationalize reality. One such way,I show,is through the selective attribution of credit and blame. With four randomized experiments,conducted in diverse national settings and containing closed-as well as open- ended questions,I find that as partisans correctly updated economic beliefs to reflect new facts,they conversely attributed responsibility in a highly selective fashion. Although partisans might acknowledge the same facts,they are apt in seizing on and producing attributional arguments that fit their preferred worldviews.

八、维和人员与暴力犯罪:

维和行动的意外影响

题目:Peacekeepers against Criminal Violence—Unintended Effects of Peacekeeping Operations?

摘要:研究显示维和人员能减少冲突的烈度,但是部署维和人员对非政治暴力的影响仍是未知的。本文聚焦于暴力犯罪并提出了一个双重机制来解释为什么维和行动——即使有效地减少了冲突——却反过来滋长了暴力犯罪。首先,较少的冲突带来了经济机会(即所谓的“维和经济”)并为有组织犯罪提供了行动时的安全环境,因此增加了犯罪集团之间的暴力竞争。其次,由于合法的谋生机会有限以及在战争中接受过的训练,复员的战斗人员很容易转向犯罪。虽然联合国部队可能会加剧这些问题,但是联合国警察的特殊作用可能会成功地遏制暴力犯罪。跨国层面和次国家层面的实证分析表明,大规模的联合国军事部署会导致更高的凶杀率,但是联合国警察在总体上缓和了这种附加影响。

Research shows that peacekeepers reduce conflict intensity; however,effects of deployment on nonpolitical violence are unknown. This article focuses on criminal violence and proposes a twofold mechanism to explain why peacekeeping missions,even when effectively reducing conflict,can inadvertently increase criminal violence. First,less conflict opens up economic opportunities (so-called peacekeeping economies) and provides operational security for organized crime,thus increasing violent competition among criminal groups. Second,demobilized combatants are vulnerable to turn to crime because of limited legal livelihood opportunities and their training in warfare. While UN troops may exacerbate these dynamics,UN police’s peculiar role is likely to successfully contain criminal violence. Cross-national and subnational empirical analyses show that large UN military deployments result in higher homicide rates,whereas UN police,overall,moderate this collateral effect.

九、贫困和神恩:

伊斯兰政党的选举优势

题目:Poverty and Divine Rewards: The Electoral Advantage of Islamist Political Parties

摘要:在穆斯林占多数的国家,政治生活的显著特征是伊斯兰政党在选举中占据主导地位。最近有研究试图解释为什么要强调它们的物质和组织因素,比如提供社会服务。在本文中,作者重新回顾了一个既有文献,它强调这些政党的宗教性质对那些陷入经济困难的选民的吸引力。遭受经济压力的个人可能会投票给伊斯兰主义者因为他们相信这是一种内在的善行,会在来世得到安拉的赏赐。作者通过一系列在突尼斯的实验室实验来验证上述假设。被灌输了经济紧张感的个人表现出对伊斯兰政党的更大支持,在这一因果关系中起到中介作用的是来世得到安拉之补偿的期望。这一证据表明伊斯兰政党的宗教性质可能是其选举成功的一个重要因素。

Political life in many Muslim-majority countries has been marked by the electoral dominance of Islamist parties. Recent attempts to explain why have highlighted their material and organizational factors,such as the provision of social services. In this article,we revive an older literature that emphasizes the appeal of these parties’ religious nature to voters experiencing economic hardship. Individuals suffering economic strain may vote for Islamists because they believe this to be an intrinsically virtuous act that will be met with divine rewards in the afterlife. We explore this hypothesis through a series of laboratory experiments in Tunisia. Individuals assigned to treatment conditions instilling feelings of economic strain exhibit greater support for Islamist parties,and this support is causally mediated by an expectation of divine compensation in the hereafter. The evidence suggests that the religious nature of Islamist parties may thus be an important factor in their electoral success.

十、话语型退出

题目:Discursive Exit

摘要:一些女性没有参加女权游行,拒绝联合和团结的主张,因为其认为白人女性仅在涉及自身利益时动员。这是一种具备三种特征的退出形式:(1)拒绝政治主张;(2)向掌权者和广大公众说明理由;(3)要求将问责制作为制裁和审议的手段,这就需要对其诉求进行讨论(在这种情况下,是对团体的意义和团体对自身的理解进行讨论)。退出、话语和审议问责制的结合可以被准确地称为“话语型退出”。话语型退出解决了标准型退出、话语和忠诚的概念性与规范性限制,特别是当退出和话语有瑕疵时(因为退出可以被视作对整个原因的反对)、有道德缺陷时(因为这种“来自内部”的话语暗示着原因大于分歧,致使人们在一种不受欢迎的权力运作中形成道德上的共谋)。

Some women did not participate in the Women's March,rejecting its claims of unity and solidarity because white women mobilize only in their self‐interest. This is a form of exit with three features: (1) rejecting a political claim; (2) providing reasons to the power wielder and the broader public; and (3) demanding accountability both as sanction and as deliberation,which requires a discussion about the claim—in this case,the meaning of the group and the terms on which it understands itself. This combination of exit,voice,and deliberative accountability might accurately be called “discursive exit.” Discursive exit addresses conceptual and normative limitations of standard accounts of exit,voice,and loyalty,in particular,when exit and voice are imperfect—because exit can be seen as disapproval of an entire cause—and morally problematic—because voice “from within” implies that cause trumps disagreement,leaving people morally complicit in an unwelcome exercise of power.

十一、当激进政党进入议会时选民会两极分化吗?

题目:Do Voters Polarize When Radical Parties Enter Parliament?

摘要:当激进的观点获得政治合法性时,选民们会出现意识形态上的两极分化吗?还是激进声音的兴起仅仅反映了社会冲突?作者认为激进政党首次进入议会昭示着精英极化,这种进场导致了选民(在意识形态上)的分歧。选举一结束,合法化和抵制效应意味着两派意识形态阵营里的选民都会走向极端。从长远来看,由于激进党派在议会的存在,这种两极分化会进一步加剧。一项针对荷兰选民的定群追踪研究显示,2002年一个激进右翼政党进入议会后确实立即导致了政治光谱中意识形态的两极分化。基于17个国家(1973-2016)的欧洲晴雨表数据所估算的时间序列截面模型显示,激进右翼政党的加入对极化产生了额外的长期影响。右翼激进声音的存在产生了极化效应,说明了这种制度认可与合法化是如何能对社会产生深远影响。

Do voters polarize ideologically when radical views gain political legitimacy,or does the rise of radical voices merely reflect societal conflict? We argue that elite polarization as signaled by radical parties' first entrance into parliament leads to voter divergence. Immediately after the election,legitimization and backlash effects mean that voters on both ideological sides move toward the extremes. In the longer term,this polarization is solidified because of radical parties' parliamentary presence. A panel study of Dutch voters shows that the 2002 parliamentary entrance of a radical‐right party indeed led to immediate ideological polarization across the political spectrum. Estimating time‐series cross‐sectional models on Eurobarometer data from 17 countries (1973–2016) shows an additional long‐term impact of radical‐right party entry on polarization. The presence of radical voices on the right has polarizing effects,illustrating how such institutional recognition and legitimization can have a far‐reaching impact on society.

十二、政党的主要偏好:

1、处在社交圈中是一种烦恼,而超脱出来简直是一场悲剧。2、厌倦,就是一个人吃完盘子里的食物后对盘子的感情。3、参加追悼会的程序常常是,先受一次深刻的人生教育,然后大家一起抽烟喝酒打牌。4、知识是一种使求知者。

族裔、性别与议会主要候选人的政党支持

题目:The Party's Primary Preferences: Race,Gender,and Party Support of Congressional Primary Candidates

摘要:政党的支持对候选人在初选中的成功当选有着强烈的影响,但是初选中政党的行为是否带有种族或性别偏见不得而知。通过对国会候选人的人口数据以及政党对主要候选人的支持程度进行测量,本文检视了政党是否在国会初选中歧视女性与少数族裔候选人,以及在某些初选中政党是否策略性地对少数族裔候选人予以支持本文的研究发现表明政党并不歧视少数族裔候选人,白人女性候选人获得民主党的支持要多于其他类型的候选人。本文的研究发现也表明了政党并不在少数族裔人口较多的地区策略性地推出少数族裔候选人来参选。最后,本文也发现政党支持对不同族裔或性别的候选人初选成功的影响不存在显著差异。

Party support has a strong influence on candidate success in the primary. What remains unexplored is whether party actions during the primary are biased along racial and gender lines. Using candidate demographic data at the congressional level and measures of party support for primary candidates,we test whether parties discriminate against women and minority candidates in congressional primaries and also whether parties are strategic in their support of minority candidates in certain primaries. Our findings show parties are not biased against minority candidates and also that white women candidates receive more support from the Democratic Party than do other types of candidates. Our findings also suggest that parties do not appear to strategically support minority candidates in districts with larger populations of minorities. Lastly,we also find no significant differences in the effects of party support on the likelihood of success in the primary by candidate race or gender.

十三、导致选举权受限的选票改革:

来自巴西第二共和国的证据

题目:Ballot Reform as Suffrage Restriction: Evidence from Brazil's Second Republic

摘要:民主制度设计中很少有创新像将统一的、正式的和无记名投票引入选举那样被认为具有根本性意义。对此,一种观点指出这些正式投票将选民从他们对当地精英的依赖中解放出来,从而强化了民主竞争。另外一种观点则反驳道,在存在大量文盲的背景下,这一举措等同于对文盲选举权的限制。本文通过对巴西第二共和国(1945-1964)时期市政议会选举的原始数据的分析讨论了这些观点。在此期间,正式选票交错展示的独特方式使人们能够以前所未有的准确性评估其影响。本文发现选票改革带来的首要后果是对选举权的限制。正式的投票不仅没有解放穷人和非独立选民,反而导致这些个体更难参与投票。此外,议会辩论表明这是改革的预期效应。

Few innovations in democratic institutional design are considered as fundamental as the introduction of voting through the use of a uniform,official,and secret ballot. One account claims that the official ballot liberates dependent voters from the dictates of local elites,thereby enhancing democratic competition. Another argues that in contexts of widespread illiteracy,its adoption may be tantamount to a suffrage restriction. This article adjudicates between these views by drawing upon an original data set of municipal‐level voting returns from Brazil's Second Republic (1945–1964). The unique staggered rollout of the official ballot during this period permits one to assess its impact with unprecedented accuracy. The article finds that the primary consequence of ballot reform was suffrage restriction. Rather than liberating poor and dependent voters,the official ballot made it exceedingly difficult for these individuals to vote. Moreover,parliamentary debates indicate that this was an anticipated and intended effect of the reform.

十四、政治中的损失规避

题目:Loss Aversion in Politics

Francesco Passarelli,都灵大学经济学教授

摘要:作者通过检视中间选民模型(在有两名候选人的选举中倾向完全趋同)和关于政策建议的局部散度模型,研究了选举中的损失规避行为。首先,作者展示了现状偏见、禀赋效应以及政策的调节效应。其次,作者证明了伴随着支持左翼或右翼的独立运动,会出现“长周期”政策现象。最后,作者证明了相较于老龄化社会,较年轻的社会应该更容易做出改变,受现状偏见的影响也更小。

We study loss aversion in elections by investigating a median voter model (full convergence in a two-candidate election) and a model of partial divergence of policy proposals. First,we show a status quo bias,an endowment effect,and a moderating effect of policies. Second,we show the occurrence of “long-term cycles” in policies with self-supporting movements to the right or the left. Finally,we prove that younger societies should be more prone to change and less affected by the status quo bias than older ones.

十五、坚定的民主人士还是有条件的民主人士?

选举威权中反对派联盟的流变

题目:Committed or Conditional Democrats? Opposition Dynamics in Electoral Autocracies

摘要:在选举式威权主义国家中,反对派的结盟为其提供了向民主转型的最大希望。然而,组建选举联盟还需要说服反对派选民忽略党派妥协,并参与到争取反对派联盟胜利所必需的跨党派投票中来。在可能导致自己并不喜欢的结果情况下,选民在多大程度上会团结一致打败在任的威权统治者。在马来西亚进行的一项调查实验发现,绝大多数反对派选民对反对派之间准备结盟的计划表示支持。但是,当面对有关哪个党派可能领导下一届政府的问题时,许多选民撤回了他们的支持。具而言之,当选民最不喜欢的成员有可能控制政府时,并且他们可以投票支持联盟之外意识形态上更贴合自己偏好的替代方案时,选民对反对派联盟的支持就会下降。尽管选民支持反对派的结盟和民主转型,但这一支持很容易受到反对派获胜的具体结果影响。

In electoral autocracies,opposition coalition formation offers the best hope of getting to democracy. Yet forming electoral coalitions also entails convincing opposition voters to ignore compromises and engage in the cross‐party voting necessary for opposition victory. To what extent are voters committed to defeating the autocratic incumbent even if it would result in dislikable outcomes? A survey experiment in Malaysia finds that opposition voters overwhelmingly express pretreatment support for the opposition coalition. But when exposed to a treatment vignette about which member party might lead the next government,many voters retract their support. Specifically,voters’ support for the coalition declines when their least preferred member is expected to control the government and when they can vote for a closer ideological alternative outside of the coalition. Although voters are committed to opposition unity and democratic transition,that commitment is sensitive to the anticipated consequences of an opposition victory.

编译/审读:康张城、施榕、杨端程、吴温泉、赵德昊

上一篇 2023年04月14 04:04
下一篇 2022年12月25 23:38

相关推荐

  • [美]彼得·门德尔桑德《当我们阅读时,我们看到了什么》作品简介与读书感悟

    彼得.门德尔桑德和奥利弗.芒戴,两位负责此书的图片部分。彼得.门德尔桑德,世界顶尖书籍装帧设计师,为600多本书籍指导和设计封面,同时也是钢琴演奏家和经典文学名著爱好者。奥利弗.芒戴,美国知名平面设计

    2022年12月24 202
  • [日]谷川俊太郎《二十亿光年的孤独》作品简介与读书感悟

    谷川俊太郎二十亿光年,二十亿光年是个长度单位,二十亿光年的孤独却是个心理情绪单位。宇宙诗人的诗是简单而不浅薄,有趣而又耐人回味。本书分为世界的约定、春的临终、小鸟在天空消失的日子、语言的胎盘、悲伤的天

    2022年12月05 250
  • VladimirGel'man《Authoritarian Russia》作品简介与读书感悟

    在芬兰,政府也考虑借鉴冰岛的经验,让集体智慧在未来决策中扮演更重要的角色。除此之外,美国加州也曾有人提议为选举制度改革设立公民大会。

    2022年12月16 219
  • [美国]卡耐基《沟通力》作品简介与读书感悟

    所推荐的书籍均有电子版可供下载阅读!特别本资料版权归原作者及原出版商所有,如果你喜欢,请购买正版!仅限个人学习之用,卡耐基的沟通与艺术,不得用于商业用途,请在下载后24小时内删除。1.《非暴力沟通》【

    2022年12月06 285
  • 冯字多少笔画,冯康熙字典11还是12

    一、文字演变二、姓氏读音拼音:féngpíng冯这个字有5画:汉字冯读音féngpíng部首冫笔画数5笔画名称点、提、横折、竖折折钩、横注音:ㄈㄥˊㄆㄧㄥˊ繁体字:馮汉字结构:左右结构造字法:冫简体部

    2023年03月15 263
  • 夏茗悠经典语录,夏茗悠八分钟的温暖经典语录

    看过这样一句深情的话:“像我这样的人,是不太喜欢结识新朋友的。你知道的,介绍自己的过去是很累的。“可遇见你那天,我竟想着要把我的前半生拍成电影给你看,夏茗悠八分钟的温暖经典语录,让你看看我见过的呼伦贝

    2022年12月08 296
  • 佛珠一般多少颗,佛珠颗数对照表

    现如今的文玩圈内,佛珠和菩提子是最常盘玩的两种文玩类型。但是佩戴佛珠、菩提子的讲究那可还真是挺多的,其中一条就是在对颗数的选择上,不同的颗数有不同的意义,这些意义,您知道多少呢?颗数的含义企业回东莞市

    2023年03月04 214
  • [法国]安东尼·德·圣-埃克苏佩里《小王子》作品简介与读书感悟

    《小王子》这本书不仅赢得了儿童读者,也为成年人所喜爱。作品凝练的语言渗透了作者对人类及人类文明深邃的思索。它所表现出的讽刺与幻想,真情与哲理,安东尼德圣埃克苏佩里英文介绍,使之成为法国乃至世界上最为著

    2022年12月05 301
  • 志字多少笔画,丧字多少笔画

    严格地说,五格数理是一种检验姓名吉凶的方法,也就是所谓的“验名法”。(1)天格天格就是人的姓氏,天格之数就是经过计算的姓氏的笔画数。此“天”有“先天”“继承”的意思,是无法选择的,原则上也不能变更,只

    2023年03月22 205
  • 范·撒普《通向财务自由之路》作品简介与读书感悟

    【哈迪读书笔记】本书要达到的两个目标是:●帮助你找到圣杯的秘密;●帮助你找到一个适合自己的成功的交易系统。首先需要说明的是,这个行业大概有两类人能够赚钱:一类人依靠行业本身赚钱,比如大的投资银行、证券

    2022年12月13 278
  • 一张a4纸多少克,50张a4纸多重

    我们古人有多精致?早在2000多年前的西汉人在炎炎夏日里已经穿上了这世上最轻薄的衣服枕着具有保健功效的驱蚊枕头其中马王堆汉墓辛追夫人的“衣柜”里就有各式各样的时尚“定制单品”除了“透视装”素纱单衣她所

    2023年03月27 260
  • 生意葱茏,生意葱茏可以形容生意吗

    一、会认的字。鲈(lú)(鲈鱼)翕(xī)(翕动)(翕张)抉(jué)(抉择)(抉挑)黛(dài)(粉黛)(黛绿)宴(yàn)(宴会)(设宴)纫(rèn)(缝纫)(纫针)1、苍山草木茂密,生意葱茏,一

    2022年12月10 252
  • [英]阿加莎·克里斯蒂《寓所谜案》作品简介与读书感悟

    人手一册1.《牛津高阶英汉双解词典》(第9版)识别二维码一键购买学写作2.《朗文英语写作活用词典》(英汉双解)世界翘首盼望的一本词典用活英语的866个关键词真正可以活学活用的案头工具书把表达相同思想和

    2022年12月06 290
关注微信